making yogurt

6 Mar

Did you know you could make your own yogurt?

I didn’t until a year or so ago when my friend, Amy, started talking about it. I’ve been wanting to try it ever since and even made it one of my food goals for 2010. Why would I want to do this? Well, I love yogurt. I eat it every day. Sometimes twice.  It’s one of the reasons I would not be a successful vegan. Because I eat it so often (as does Brette), I buy a lot of yogurt. I figure if I could make my own, I would spend about 50% less on the stuff. Not to shabby. There is also the bonus of not having so many yogurt containers to toss. My great city will not recycle yogurt containers and although I reuse the larger tubs, they ultimately end up in the trash.

Last weekend, I finally gave the yogurt a whirl.  My first try was a complete success! Today, I’m making it again. Just as I had suspected, it’s super easy and as it turns out, it tastes awesome. I encourage you to step outside your comfort zone and give it a try.

All you need is milk,  a little bit of yogurt (plain), a pot, a kitchen thermometer, a couple of quart sized mason jars, and a cooler.

Happy cows make happy milk which makes happy yogurt.

I did look at some other ways to make yogurt, but I settled on this one for 2 reasons. 1. I didn’t need any fancy equipment like a yogurt maker. 2. I didn’t need to use my oven. This will be especially nice come summer.

Do it yourself Yogurt

Per my dear friend Amy

Note: this makes plain yogurt. After it’s made, you can add all the sugary goodness you want, but don’t do it during the cooking process.  You might even find, you like the tang of plain yogurt and maybe some fruit mixed in. I highly recommend it. My new favorite mix-in is chopped dates. Yum.


4 C. Milk – preferably organic – get the best milk you can. My friend Amy likes it with whole milk, but I used 2%. I might try skim in the future, but I really like the 2%.

1/3 C. plain yogurt with live cultures – again you can use either whole or 2%. I have not tried it with non-fat. You can also use some of the yogurt from the last batch you made – if you get to that point.

Bring milk up to 180 degrees in a pot. If you are like me, you use your candy thermometer, but test it with an instant-read thermometer because you don’t trust the other one.

Not quite hot enough.

Turn off the heat and let cool until it reaches 116 degrees. Stir in yogurt. Pour contents into one of the mason jars. Fill the other jar with almost boiling water.

Place both jars, touching, into a small cooler, wrap with a kitchen towel and close the cooler. Let it rest, undisturbed, for 8-12 hours depending on what you have going on during the day. The closer you get to 12 hours, the thicker it will be. It will also continue to thicken in the fridge.

As mentioned above, you could mix-in a number of different fruits (fresh or dried), or mix it with either summer or winter granola. You surely will enjoy the fact that you made it yourself. I believe that automatically makes it taste better.

Are any of you already do-it-yourself yogurt makers? All tips and pointers are welcome!

Let me know if you have any questions.


4 Responses to “making yogurt”

  1. Meghan March 7, 2010 at 10:51 am #

    Mine’s all wrapped up in the cooler. I added Vanilla when I added the starter. After all said and done realized the “Pure Vanilla Extract” has sugar in it. awesome:(

  2. Willa March 8, 2010 at 9:59 am #

    Congrats on your yogurt making success! My method is different but the results are equally delicious. I am going to give yours a whirl, especially because I am tired of paying $2 per container of yogurt. Buen provecho!


  1. sugar-free update #3 « She said. She said. - March 10, 2010

    […] note above under ‘Things I’m craving that I can’t have’.  I also made homemade yogurt . I added vanilla only to find out afterward that so called ‘PURE Vanilla Extract’ has sugar […]

  2. a year in review « She said. She said. - December 30, 2010

    […] And it’s completely easy. You can read all about it here. I have kind of gotten away from it over the summer, but will get back into the swing of it […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: